Our ‘Beat The Press Party’ Bakeoff (Welfare Roils Edition)

This week’s Great Boston MediaWatch Dogfight saw the Boston Herald’s Press Party ppteaseaddressing “[t]he media’s handling of a scathing audit claiming the state has handed out more than $2 million in welfare benefits to dead people . . . ratings for MSNBC dive as support for the Bruins rises. Plus the #mediafail of the week.”

Not surprisingly, the Herald chinstrokers whacked the Boston Globe for downplaying the welfare story, and lionized the feisty local tabloid for playing it up.

Crosstown, WGBH’s Beat the Press (full disclosure: blah blah blah) had a segment headlined “Boston Herald Spotlights Welfare Fraud” and also discussed – well, we’re not sure, because all the website says is this:

Sometimes a dog with a bone is a good thing, a case in point Screen_Shot_2013-05-31_at_8.01.07_PMbeing the Boston Herald’s persistent coverage of welfare abuse and EBT card fraud. This week, the state auditor released a report validating the Herald’s reporting.

Oh, yes – and this:

Ugh! We are having a temporary problem with our video compression server. We hope to have the video posted soon. Sorry for the inconvenience.

Yeah, ditto.

 

This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to Our ‘Beat The Press Party’ Bakeoff (Welfare Roils Edition)

  1. Curmudgeon's avatar Curmudgeon says:

    You mean you don’t watch Emily and Dan in real time?

    There goes your annual Christmas card from them.

    I sure do miss listening to Calley though. Best part of the show.

    • Campaign Outsider's avatar Campaign Outsider says:

      Actually, Mudge, my Xmas card was Xed out years ago.

      ________________________________________

  2. Bob Gardner's avatar Bob Gardner says:

    Beat the press is posted to the comcast On demand section (Local-Local networks–wgbh–) on the same night is is broadcast.
    Only Dan Kennedy noted that the rate of fraud is actually pretty low. But even he joined in general consensus, ie. that overplaying a story about welfare (to the point of falsifying it, in my opinion) is praiseworthy because the Herald is a TABLOID and that’s what TABLOIDS do. The bigotry of low expectations.

    • Campaign Outsider's avatar Campaign Outsider says:

      Thanks, Bob. Actually, the show without a link just isn’t blogworthy. Call me superficial, but there it is.

      ________________________________________

  3. Michael Pahre's avatar Michael Pahre says:

    The real question is: when will somebody audit the state auditor’s work? According to the governor, her report is full of lots of mistakes, i.e., people she thought dead but who are alive and qualify for those benefits.

    Even if most of the auditor’s cases turn out to be bogus — which I doubt — will the feisty tabloid throw in the towel? Of course not, because theirs is journalism by anecdotal evidence, not by thorough investigation. All it takes is one fraud case for the Herald-istas to declare the welfare system corrupt.

    • Campaign Outsider's avatar Campaign Outsider says:

      There’s a fair amount of skepticism out there, Mike – see Adrian Walker’s Globe column last week for a representative sample.

      But you’re right – that will never stop the Herald Excess (sorry, Express). ________________________________________

Leave a comment